Should You Choose a Male or Female Therapist?

As a licensed professional therapist and the owner of two group practices that specialize in gender-specific care, I understand that the decision of whether to choose a male or female therapist is a very personal one. It depends not only on your needs and preferences but also on who makes you feel safe. Who do you find an easier connection with? This connection is crucial to the therapeutic process. Who are you able to take constructive feedback from? While there is no right or wrong answer, understanding how each gender may approach counselling can help determine which type of therapist is right for you.


How Gender Influences Therapy

Gender can influence both the style and content of therapy, so it’s essential to consider both the psychological and sociological aspects when selecting a therapist. Studies have found that both men and women tend to prefer a same-gender therapist because they feel more comfortable and trust their therapists more. Additionally, research has indicated that male clients generally prefer male therapists who are more directive and authoritative. In contrast, female clients tend to prefer female therapists who are more nurturing and supportive.

Individual Differences and Therapeutic Approaches

When considering gender, it’s essential to remember that each individual is unique in their gender identity and whom they will work best within the therapeutic setting. No two people experience the same process in counselling. However, some studies have indicated that specific approaches may be more effective for particular genders. For example, one study found that male clients responded better to a direct, problem-solving approach than female clients, who responded better to an emotional exploration approach. Different modalities also pair with these specific approaches, which is an important question to ask your therapist (regardless of gender) during your consultation call.

Gender-Specific Benefits in Therapy

Male clients may benefit from a figure who demonstrates both vulnerability and guidance. Sociological influences and pressures on men may discourage vulnerability and “not knowing” the answer. Therapy creates a safe space for this type of exploration.

Female clients may appreciate a supportive figure who offers emotional understanding and validation. In a patriarchal society, the complexity of women’s (and just human) emotions can be shut down, similar to men’s. Validation creates the space to explore further our uniqueness, which creates greater insight and confidence in understanding ourselves at our core.

It’s important to note that these qualities can be sought after in both male and female therapists. Understanding the qualities rather than the gender of the therapists that best suit your needs may be the most rational place to start when seeking out therapy.

How Gender Affects Counseling

Gender can have a significant impact on the counselling process. Depending on the client’s preference and the type of therapy they are seeking, gender can influence the overall effectiveness of treatment.

The first factor to consider when exploring how gender affects counselling is the client’s preferences. Clients may find that they are more comfortable speaking to one gender over the other, or they may prefer a specific gender for certain topics or issues. Some clients might like the therapeutic rapport with a male or female counsellor because of gender-related attributes such as communication style, personality, or mannerisms. Ultimately, the therapist must be a good match for the client, regardless of gender—but a client may be more likely to find sameness with a same-gender therapist when sifting through the immense options of therapists online.

The Difference Between the Male and Female Brain in Counseling

Another factor to consider when considering gender in counselling is the difference between male and female brains. There are some biological differences between the two genders, which can affect how a therapist approaches counseling sessions. Studies have shown that men are more task-oriented and analytical, while women often use their feelings and emotions to approach situations.

This means that male counsellors may be better suited for career guidance or decision-making, while female counsellors may be more adept at providing emotional support and helping clients express their feelings.

Differences in the way men and women process information and experiences can also affect the types of therapeutic approaches used. For example, males may benefit from cognitive-behavioural therapy, which focuses on changing behaviour through practical solutions, while females may prefer therapies that focus on deeper emotional connections.

Additionally, the counsellor’s gender can affect the dynamics between the patient and therapist. Depending on the client’s issues and preferences, they may be more comfortable with a male or female therapist.

The Bottom Line: Personal Preference Matters Most

Ultimately, choosing a male or female therapist should be based on the individual’s needs and preferences. Clients must feel comfortable and supported by their therapist to get the most out of counselling. If you’re looking for counselling in Coquitlam many options are available to suit your individual needs.

Remember, the best therapist for you is one who makes you feel heard, understood, and safe—regardless of their gender. Take the time to consider what qualities are most important to you in a therapist and use those as your guide in finding the right fit.

Related Stories